Short-term capital loss from a transaction can be set-off against short-term capital gain from any transaction at the option of the taxpayer

S. 70, 115AD; A/y 2005-06; in favor of taxpayer:- Taxpayer, a FII, earned short-term capital gains on sale of shares which it bifurcated as pre and post 30 September 2004 (pre and  post STT), chargeable to tax at 30% and 10%, respectively under section 115AD. It also suffered short-term capital loss during both these periods. It set-off pre-STT short-term capital loss against pre-STT short-term capital gain and also post-STT short- term capital loss against left over balance of pre-STT short-term capital gain. The Revenue, however, al owed set-off of post-STT short-term capital loss only against post-STT short-term capital gain.

On appeal, held, under section 70(2), the option is with the taxpayer to decide as to whether the short-term capital loss from the first transaction ought to be set-off against the short-term capital gain of transaction No. 2, 3 or 4, etc., as the case may  be, whether within or outside the cut-off date. Thus, the higher benefit opted by the taxpayer by exercising such option was to be allowed.

Decided by ITAT – Mumbai in the case of First State Investments (Hongkong) Ltd. vs. ADIT (Intl. Tax.) [2009] 33 SOT 26 (Mum)

Related posts:

1. Set-off of short-term capital losses, subject to STT, allowable against short-term capital gains not subject to STT
2. The option to or not to avail the benefit of indexation for the computation of capital gains on the transfer of each of the long term capital asset is with the assessee
3. SC to decide on ‘dividend stripping’ by mutual funds for creating a short-term loss to avoid tax
4. Foreign companies can also claim benefit of lower Rate of Tax on Capital Gain from securities transaction
5. Income from Share Trading – Business Gain or capital Gain?