Many thanks for the basic info.

We would like to know complete Act, procedure of Registration , Bombay Municipal Corporation/ Maharashtra Municipal Corporation fees for registration etc., for our business,and our clients, so if L.B.T. is levied in Mumbai Dist. and Thane City, then we are prepared for it.

Anticipating update on our quarry.

I don’t know from how many years your goodself is practicing law. You may be too good at law and a very good advocate. But i am also a smart(budding) CA. I am smart enough to understand Para No.17.2 of Circular No.387, Dt.06.07.1984.

It reads as under-
A proper audit for tax purposes would ensure that the books of account and other records are properly maintained, that they faithfully reflect the income of the taxpayer and claims or deduction are correctly made by him. Such audit would also help in checking fraudulent practices. It can also facilitate the administration of tax law laws by a proper presentation of the accounts before the tax authorities and considerably saving the time of AOs in carrying out routine verifications, like checking correctness of totals and verifying whether purchases and sales are properly vouched or not. The time of the AOs thus saved could be utilised for attending to more important investigational aspects of a case.

Kindly go through the above para and try to understand the words “also”, “like”, if you can understand.

Anyway you people(advocates) are biased and read out any that part of law which benefits you. Rest of Non-CAs as defined by your goodself as professionals are not even bothered to understand these things. That is the reason the parliament went to CA for audit.

I bravely claim that given an opportunity for doing audit u/s 44AB to Non-CAs, such Non-CAs would not be able to detect wrong claims made by the assessee and fradulent activities.

One more thing for your information all the comments are made by so called professionals like lions fighting for flesh. You people are eying on the money involved in Tax audits and certifications and definitely without the knowledge of responsibilities. No client to say business men complained about their CAs.Mind it.

Do not try to bias the information with your supreme skills to read out a piece of law.

I regret that advocates have become desperate to earn money. Kindly take up CA course and finish off in no time as you claim to be an expert. You will earn good amount of money.

In my opinion, the version of Mr. B.S.K. Rao has been misunderstood. The author has not questioned about the ability of C.A’s anywhere. It is not a debatable point whther C.A’s are Masters or other Professionals. What I understand from the letter of the author is since Income Tax Act is a law (I hope the learneds will defenitly understand), it is unfair to authorize only C.A’s to sign the reports since it is only certifying whether the accounts maintained by the assessee are in confirmity with the law. It is unfair and unacceptable to restrict an advocate who is specially authorized to practice any law from signing the reports for the purpose of Income Tax Act. What will be the position of C.A’s if restrictions are imposed on them from signing the P & L A/c and Balance Sheet?. Instead of calling advocates as unqualifed for the purpose of Income Tax Law, mend your mentality and think with broad mind.

I have two ppf ac. 1st post office in 2011 & 2nd Sbi in 2013.
I thought of transfer from post office Account to SBI, but post master is not accepting the new Accont Id given by SBI .

how to transfer from PostOffice to SBI ?
how to close Post office account ( they are not accepting) ?

waiting for your reply.

regards
Nishok

Kindly do the needful

Thanking you

Yours faithfully

I can’t understand if all are so fascinated by the brand and status of CA profession then why not they all join CA course!

If CA, CS and CWA curriculum is equally challenging then why people leave CA course before qualifying and join some LL.b or CS courses?????

Being a businessman I have met and appointed some CAs, CSs and Advocates. And I personally feel that all they have their own field of specialization i.e.
CAs in TAX and FINANCE sector and
CSs in Companies Law matters and
Advocates in court matters.

In fact many of other businessmen in my circle have the same opinion.

So I’m unable to understand why Advocate Mr. B.S.K Rao has posted this article!!!

this is use full to all

The IT Expert may kindly calculate and mail me the details of calculation in this regard to my e-mail Id .

CAs are not allowed to practice medicine,
CAs are not allowed to appear in Courts,
CAs are not allowed to certify secretarial complaince,

Then why many people claiming the rights of CAs without passing the CA exam? Just go and right the CA exam and pass before claiming the rights for Non-CAs. Once you pass out CA, you will realise the toughness went through by the CAs. Dont pass comments without passing the qualifications prescribed by the people’s representatives in Parliament.

Does he add this cost into PSF rate or he charge additionally?